Skip to main content
This page is displayed using automated translation. View in US English instead?
CASE STUDY

Retrofitting Gives Spinning Machines New Lease on Life

Safilin’s plant in Szczytno has given new life to an old spinning machine. Retrofitting the equipment helped reduce costs, increase production efficiency and safety, and improve working comfort.

Safilin, a company combining French capital with Polish expertise, manufactures flax- and hemp-based products, including yarns used in the apparel, furniture, technical textiles, food, automotive, and many other industries. The company also produces rovings for composite materials, as well as twines and twisted yarns for a variety of applications. In Poland, Safilin operates production facilities in Miłakowo and Szczytno. The latter site houses both a wet spinning mill and a combing plant. The facility produces approximately 2,000 tonnes of finished products annually. For wet spinning, it uses PM88 machines, commonly referred to as PMs. These machines have been in operation since 1982, meaning they have been running for more than 40 years. As part of its industrial strategy, the company decided to explore alternatives to its existing equipment and leverage its deep process expertise to build a competitive advantage in flax yarn production. Seeking to make the most of its existing assets, the management team launched a retrofit program aimed at giving the PM machine a second life while renaming it the PZ-KA. The decision to modernize the aging machines enabled the automation of processes and the real-time visualization of production parameters, resulting in improved operational efficiency and significant cost savings. A key success factor was the creation of a comprehensive project team, bringing together Safilin specialists from various disciplines who actively contributed to the initiative.

Safilin - Retrofitting - Case study - 01

The PM88 spinning machine after modernization. Retrofitting the equipment helped reduce costs, increase production efficiency and safety, and improve working comfort.

The alternative to retrofitting was purchasing machines from China. However, we chose modernization because the equipment currently available on the market does not guarantee the required level of quality or productivity. In addition, its cost is higher than refurbishing and upgrading our existing machine fleet. The payback period for a new machine would exceed eight years, whereas for the retrofit it is less than two years. That is why the modernized PZ-KA has become part of the spinning department’s machine park,”
says Jan Słowiński, Plant Director at Safilin Szczytno.

The Complex Process of Flax Processing

The flax spinning process involves drafting and simultaneously twisting a chemically treated roving, that is, a pre-processed and slightly twisted flax sliver of a specified linear density.

At the Szczytno facility, spinning is carried out using the wet-spinning method. A roving bobbin is placed on the spinning frame, where the ‘spinning preparation’ process begins. This involves passing the roving through a water bath maintained at 18–22°C and then through a series of guides that allow it to unwind gradually and in a controlled manner,
explains Aleksandra Kaszubowska, Process Engineer at Safilin.

W kolejnej fazie taśma niedoprzędu wprowadzana jest do zestawu wałów. W obszarze między wałem zasilającym a wałkiem wydającym następuje połączenie niedoprzędu z przędzą i rozpoczyna się proces przędzenia. Przędza nawijana jest następnie na cewkę umieszczoną na wrzecionie. Aby osiągnąć optymalną wytrzymałość i równomierność przędzy należy kontrolować prędkość, skręt, wielkość rozciągu i kilka innych parametrów. Stało się to w pełni możliwe dopiero po retrofittingu, automatyzacji procesów i wdrożeniu rozwiązań do monitorowania.

Initial Condition Before Modernization

The PM88 machine consisted of three main components: an electrical cabinet, a mechanical cabinet, and a working module. The mechanical cabinet was designed to transmit drive power through a system of gears, chains, and belts. In fact, the entire mechanism, comprising approximately 50 components, primarily spur gears, was driven by a single electric motor.

This solution made it difficult to change machine parameters, as it required manual intervention, including replacing gears to alter transmission ratios. In addition, mechanical adjustment components had to be used, such as a ratchet mechanism for controlling cyclic motion. This required precise setting adjustments and prolonged the time needed to adapt the machine to a new product range,
recalls Aneta Siemak, Supervisor of the Spinning Department.

In addition, some drivetrain components, such as shafts and bearing assemblies, were not properly adapted to the machine’s operating conditions, leading to more frequent failures and malfunctions that affected the machine’s reliability and uptime,” adds Krzysztof Ogonowski, Chief Mechanical Engineer in the Spinning Department.

The electrical system of the conventional PM88 machine contained only the minimum number of components required to power the control system and drives. The entire control diagram for the machine fit on a single sheet. “This was due to the machine’s limited functionality,” explains Aneta Siemak.

The main motor drove all machine components, including the feed rollers, drafting rollers, and the ring rail oscillation mechanism,” she adds.

The motor was powered directly from a 3×400 V mains supply. The number of detection devices, namely limit switches, was restricted to confirming the end positions of mechanical mechanisms. The control system performed only basic functions: start-up, stop, and cycle completion.

Safilin - Retrofitting - Case study - 03

Before modernization, the mechanical cabinet was designed to transmit power through a system of gears, chains, and belts. The entire drivetrain was powered by a single electric motor.
The retrofit gave the machine a new lease on life. As part of the modernization process, the mechanical cabinet was redesigned and adapted for the installation of servo motors.

Zmiany po modernizacji

Work on the retrofit project began in May 2023 and continued until July 2024. The entire mechanical cabinet was redesigned and adapted for the installation of servo motors. During the modernization, several components were replaced, including the gear train, which was substituted with servo-driven systems. Bearing assemblies and drive shafts were also modified to operate under the new conditions. These changes enabled precise adjustment of machine operating parameters, significantly improving overall performance.

Thanks to the servo motors, there is no longer any need for manual intervention in the drive system, eliminating the requirement to replace gears. Machine parameters are now adjusted through the PLC controller. In addition, we have full visibility of every parameter within each working section of the machine, allowing for quick and easy reconfiguration of settings and optimization of the production process,” says Maciej Rusinek, Chief Energy Engineer at Safilin.

We optimized the durability of key power transmission components, such as bearings, shafts, and other assemblies, which has significantly improved the reliability of the entire system,” adds Kamil Baran, Mechanical Engineer at Safilin.

The reduction in the number of mechanical components has also made maintenance easier by providing better access to critical parts, significantly reducing downtime. Altogether, these improvements have contributed to higher machine efficiency and greater operational reliability.

Following the modernization, the PM88 machine’s electrical system incorporates components aligned with the concept of the modified drive systems, as well as new functions introduced to meet production requirements. These solutions are based on Siemens technologies, which met Safilin’s expectations and proved ideally suited for the machine retrofit project,” explains Jakub Chojnacki, Senior Technical Support Specialist at Siemens.

The main drive element remains an asynchronous motor; however, its function has been limited to driving the spindles. Thanks to the specialized design of the SIMOTICS GP (VSD) motor and the modular SINAMICS G120 frequency converter, its performance capabilities have been significantly enhanced. The remaining drive components responsible for process-specific functions utilize SINAMICS S210 servo drive systems combined with high-performance, high-dynamic SIMOTICS S-1FK2 permanent-magnet synchronous servo motors and SIMOGEAR 2KJ gearboxes.

The number of physical control elements on the operator panel has been reduced to zero by transferring all operating functions to the HMI panel. The only physical controls remaining are those connected to the safety system, namely the emergency stop buttons and safety circuit reset controls,” explains Wiktor Bartko, Automation Specialist at Safilin.

The new solution has also been equipped with a utility shut-off function that automatically cuts off supporting media, namely water and compressed air, when the machine is powered down. Additional features include automatic water replenishment in the machine trough and automatic cooling of both the electrical and mechanical cabinets. The entire control system is managed by a reliable Siemens S7-1500 family controller working in conjunction with the HMI panel.

Safilin - Retrofitting - Case study - 07 img 01

Electrical Control Cabinet Before Modernization.

Case study - 07 img 02

Electrical Control Cabinet After Modernization.

Automation That Enhances Productivity and Safety

Thanks to the retrofit, the safety of machine operation has also been significantly improved. The PZ-KA is now equipped with a new safety system designed in accordance with the requirements identified through the risk assessment process. Among other features, the machine has been fitted with standard mushroom-type emergency stop buttons.

The safety system is supervised by a programmable safety relay from the SIRIUS 3SK2 family. In addition to the basic emergency stop function, an unlock request function has also been implemented, enabling the machine to be brought to a safe stop,” says Ewelina Radomska, Health, Safety and Environmental Specialist.

Safe stopping of the machine drives can also be achieved through the safety circuits and safety functions integrated into the servo drives and frequency converter. These functions operate based on signals generated by the safety relay, enabling a rapid response in hazardous situations. At the same time, while safety has been significantly improved, the machine’s productivity has also increased.

Przemiennik częstotliwości SINAMICS G120 odpowiada za prędkość wrzecion. Zastosowana technika 87Hz pozwala na uzyskanie obrotów silnika połączonego w trójkąt do 2610 RPM, zwiększając maksymalną liczbę obrotów na wrzecionach do około 12 tysięcy RPM. Stanowi to wzrost o 173%
Maciej Rusinek, chief energy engineer, Safilin
Safilin - Retrofitting - Case study - 10 img

Operator Panel Before and After Modernization.

Automation is controlled by the Siemens CPU integrated into the SIMATIC S7-1500 controller, which coordinates the operation of the servo drives and other machine components. Among its functions are the synchronization of drive speeds and processes, as well as the control of solenoid valves and ventilation systems. The TP1200 Comfort HMI operator panel, in turn, manages the machine’s basic functions. It enables diagnostics of system components, including the drives, and provides control and monitoring of process parameters. The panel also visualizes key operating data, such as the fill level of the bobbin onto which the yarn is wound.

The HMI panel displays the length of yarn wound, measured in metres, as well as the duration of the process. It allows operators to adjust current process settings based on laboratory test results and generates positional graphs for the ring rail servo drive,” explains Wiktor Bartko.

Achieving Optimal Production

The machine modernization project included a wide range of activities related to technological integration and the implementation of new IT solutions. The primary objective of this part of the project was to create a system capable of digitally collecting production data, processing it, and analyzing it to optimize manufacturing processes.

The data collected makes it possible to recreate a complete picture of the machine’s operation, allowing us to identify potential issues, plan corrective actions, and improve operational efficiency. More than 120 machine parameters are recorded, the most important of which include spindle speed, ring rail oscillation, feed rate, and delivery rate,” says Jan Słowiński.

In addition, machine operating time and downtime are monitored, making it possible to assess process efficiency and energy consumption, which in turn supports effective cost control. Data is also collected on production volumes, product quality, and waste generation. At the technological level, digital data exchange with the machine is carried out using Modbus communication protocols and APIs. Modbus provides reliable connectivity with control devices, while APIs enable flexible integration with other IT systems. By combining these two technologies, it is possible to collect data in real time and transmit consolidated reports to servers for further analysis.

As part of the project, application servers were configured to collect live production data. Data transmission is streamlined by the Node-RED process orchestration environment, which enables the automation of data flows between different systems. Combined with the cron scheduling utility, it gives us complete flexibility in defining when and how information is transmitted. All machine data collected is stored in an SQL database,” explains Maciej Chudziński, Software Engineer at Safilin.

The final stage of the IT implementation was the development of a data visualization system in Power BI. This platform enables the creation of interactive reports and analytical dashboards that provide users with clear and dynamic insights into production performance. These visualizations support the identification of issues and facilitate data-driven decision-making.

Safilin - Retrofitting - Case study - 13

The key element of the project was the people involved in it. As Jan Słowiński points out, without their dedication and expertise, the PM88 retrofit would not have been possible.

Benefits of the Retrofit

The results achieved through the modernization of the PM88 have been so successful that the plant is planning to retrofit additional machines. According to the project assumptions, the return on investment is expected to be achieved in just over one year. Other benefits include increased operational safety and a significant improvement in working conditions, thanks to a reduction in noise levels from 94 dB to 89.5 dB. The quality of the finished product has also improved, particularly in terms of strength and yarn evenness. Owing to the implemented IT solutions, yarn quality indicators are now continuously monitored in Power BI.

The financial benefits stem primarily from lower yarn production costs, achieved through an approximately 19% increase in machine productivity. In absolute terms, average output rose from 176 kg per day to 209.5 kg per day.

The automation system, built around the SIMATIC S7-1500 controller, the flexible adjustment of process parameters through the HMI, and the continuous monitoring of energy consumption, including the kWh/kg indicator, have helped the Szczytno plant achieve significant cost reductions. Safilin’s decision to invest in retrofitting, and the positive outcome of the project, demonstrate that this approach is not only environmentally beneficial but also economically viable for the company,” emphasizes Sławomir Kalita, Sales Manager at Siemens Poland.