Go to content

SIEMENS

Research & Development
Technology Press and Innovation Communications

Dr. Ulrich Eberl
Herr Dr. Ulrich Eberl
  • Wittelsbacherplatz 2
  • 80333 Munich
  • Germany
Dr. Ulrich Eberl
Herr Florian Martini
  • Wittelsbacherplatz 2
  • 80333 Munich
  • Germany
pictures

Hydroelectric generation capacity on the Jinsha River is being expanded.
The resulting electricity will be transmitted to major cities on China’s southeastern coast by the world’s most powerful HVDCT line.

Hydroelectric generation capacity on the Jinsha River is being expanded.
The resulting electricity will be transmitted to major cities on China’s southeastern coast by the world’s most powerful HVDCT line.

Giant 800 kV transformers were tested in Nuremberg...

...before being shipped to China for installation.

The control room of the transmission station in Lufeng

A gate at the Guangzhou receiving station alerts visitors to its world-record transmission voltage.

Hydropower and HVDCT are cutting China’s CO2 emissions by 33 million metric tons a year.

Hydropower and HVDCT are cutting China’s CO2 emissions by 33 million metric tons a year.

China’s River of Power

How do you supply five million households with hydroelectric power from a distance of 1,400 km? The answer is: with high-voltage direct-current transmission. Siemens is building the world’s most powerful such system in China.

Image
Image
Image Giant 800 kV transformers were tested in Nuremberg before being shipped to China for installation. The control room of the transmission station in Lufeng.

With HVDC, 95 percent of the power is transmitted; with AC, 87 percent - the equivalent of 400 megawatts less.

Image
Image
Image A gate at the Guangzhou receiving station alerts visitors to its world-record transmission voltage. Hydropower and HVDCT are cutting China’s CO2 emissions by 33 million tons a year

Plugging into HVDC’s Advantages

open

High-voltage direct-current transmission (HVDCT) is ideal for countries where power has to be transported over long distances. HVDCT becomes financially viable from around 1,000 megawatts and 600 kilometers upward. The 1,400-kilometer HVDCT line between the Chinese provinces of Yunnan and Guangdong will transmit at 800,000 volts, a new world record. Compared to a 765 kV alternating- current (AC) line of the same length, which would require immense compensation for transmission losses, HVDCT will save around 36 percent in costs over a 30-year service life. In the case of undersea cables, the advantages of HVDCT come into play over distances as small as 60 kilometers. Over longer distances, AC lines act like huge capacitors that are charged and discharged 50 times a second, eventually losing virtually all their power. This effect can be compensated for by the use of coils, but such measures are not economical for underwater cables. As of May 2011, for example, a 250 kV HVDCT line from Siemens will connect the Balearic Islands with the Spanish mainland, 250 kilometers away, and carry 400 megawatts of power. The forthcoming boom in offshore wind farms will provide a further boost for the HVDCT market. HVDC PLUS is an innovative system from Siemens that features a new generation of power converter. With its compact dimensions, it is designed to provide flexible and reliable transmission from offshore wind plants. HVDCT back-to-back links are a special instance of this technology. The principle is the same as the one governing a normal HVDC transmission system, except that the transmission and receiving stations are on the same site. Their purpose is to link different AC power networks with dissimilar voltages and frequencies by converting alternating current into direct current and then back again. HVDCT is also increasingly being incorporated into synchronous three-phase AC networks, both for long-distance transmission and to provide back-to-back links. This is because, as Prof. Dietmar Retzmann explains, HVDCT has the major advantage over AC transmission that it acts like a firewall, automatically halting cascading failures within a network and thus greatly reducing the risk of a major blackout. So-called gas-insulated lines (GILs), meanwhile, are ideal for transmitting high power in urban environments, where space — the cheapest form of insulation — is usually at a premium. The lines are laid underground in a 50-centimeter pipe filled with a low-pressure gaseous mixture of nitrogen and sulfur hexafluoride. This gas insulates the conductor so well that a power of up to 3,500 megawatts can be transmitted at 550 kilovolts. GILs require little maintenance and they do not deface the landscape. As a rule, they are used in major cities, where it is impossible to build high-voltage overhead lines. In terms of construction costs alone, GILs are between five and ten times more expensive than overhead lines. However, this extra cost become smaller once the costs of land and maintenance for overhead lines are factored into the equation. What’s more, GILs become even more attractive economically at higher transmission loads. Another advantage of GILs is that the metal pipes that encase them block electromagnetic radiation. This was an important consideration for the operators of the Palexpo congress center in Geneva, where a Siemens-built GIL under the exhibition halls ensures that visitors and sensitive electronic systems are shielded from radiation fields.

close

It takes a jarring ninety-minute ride to cover the distance from Kunming, the capital of Yunnan province in southwestern China, to Lufeng. Lush green paddy fields and herds of water buffalo flash by the car window. Then, at long last, deliverance comes. Our driver turns in at a blue sign bearing lots of Chinese characters and "800 kV" in Western script and lets us out just beyond a rolling gate. In front of us is a site measuring around 700 by 300 m that looks like something from another world. Gigantic pylons dripping with cables soar into the cloudy sky, while workers below toil with spades and wooden wheelbarrows to finish the last of the landscaping. The air is alive with a sonorous hum. "That’s from the testing," explains Jürgen Sawatzki, who is in charge of the installation of equipment from Siemens at the site.

The high-voltage overhead lines coming from the hills to the left of the fence are already carrying power, but the shiny new one that crosses the fence to the right and disappears over the mountain is still dead. It will go into operation in 2010 as a bipolar line transmitting power to Guangzhou in Guangdong province, over 1,400 kilometers away. From there it will supply five million households in the megacities Guangzhou, Shenzhen, and Hong Kong on China’s southeastern seaboard. This will reduce the country’s annual emissions of CO2 by some 33 mill. t a year, as the electricity comes from a dozen hydroelectric plants on the Jinsha ("Golden Sand") River, one of the headwaters of the Yangtze, which provide carbon-free power.

The overhead lines arriving from the left of the site are carrying conventional alternating current (AC) that has been generated by hydroelectric plants, some of which are located as far as several hundred kilometers away. The 1,400-km transmission line to Guangzhou, however, will carry direct current. High-voltage direct-current transmission (HVDCT) is not a new invention; as long ago as 1882, a transmission line of this type carried electricity from Miesbach in Bavaria to an electricity exhibition in Munich, 57 km away. That, however, is where the similarities end. Back then the voltage was a mere 1,400 V; in China, the line will transmit at a record 800,000 V. "The HVDCT line in China is the ultimate example of this technology. It will carry 5,000 MW; that’s the output of five large power plants," explains Prof. Dietmar Retzmann, one of Siemens’ top experts on HVDCT.

Low-loss Power. Regardless of whether power is transmitted as an alternating or a direct current, the goal is to ramp up the voltage as much as possible. For both types of transmission, physics dictates that for a fixed amount of transmitted power, the current is inversely proportional to the voltage. In other words, the higher the voltage, the lower the current, thus reducing the energy losses that result from the conductor heating up. When transmitting over long distances, however, HVDCT is superior.

"With our power highway in China, as much as 95 % of the power reaches the consumer," says Wolfgang Dehen, CEO of Siemens Energy. With AC transmission lines, this falls to 87 %, which in this case would amount to a loss of 400 MW — the output of a mid-sized power plant or 160 wind generators. As a result of these reduced transmission losses, the HVDCT link will cut emissions by a further three million metric tons of CO2 a year.

In theory, it would be possible to build AC transmission lines over similar distances. A voltage of 800 kV will transmit an alternating current over a distance of 1,500 km. The problem is, however, that over long distances the voltage waves at the beginning and the end of the transmission line are shifted relative to one another — the technical phrase here is "phase angle" — and this necessitates the installation of large banks of capacitors every few hundred kilometers for the purposes of series compensation. This drives up the price of such installations. And in spite of such compensation, the losses over long distances would still be significantly higher than with HVDCT.

Sawatzki leads us into a hall the size of an aircraft hangar, where workers are installing a power stabilization system onto long poles suspended from the 20-m-high ceiling — a measure designed to minimize the chances of a short circuit and associated electrical outage even in the event of an earthquake. The devices look like a stack of huge plant trays and could well have been inspired by the legendary Hanging Gardens of Babylon. Each tray contains a total of 30 shiny golden cans that are carefully connected in series and wired to control circuits with fiber optic cables (see article "The Art of Converting Volts").

Inside the tins are thyristors — converter valves made of silicon, molybdenum, and copper — which are activated optically by means of a laser beam 50 times a second, exactly in phase with the current as it switches polarity. This occurs so precisely — to within a millionth of a second — that the negative waves of the alternating current are "flipped" so as to create a direct current. Because this current still has a high ripple content, it next goes to the so-called "DC yard" right behind the valve hall. There, capacitors temporarily store charge, which they "inject" into the ripples, and coils filter out interference signals emanating from the rectifiers in the hall. All this is standard circuitry, as found in any mains-operated electrical appliance, but the dimensions are gigantic here in the DC yard.

Bipolar Transmission. In another hall right next to the first one, the screed floor is being poured. Sawatzki draws a circuit diagram on a piece of cardboard and explains: "The rectifiers and the DC yard are in duplicate." The advantage here is that one conductor is operated as an 800 kV positive pole and the other as an 800 kV negative pole, thus giving a total of 1.6 mill. V between them. In other words, the power is divided between two conductors in order to minimize transmission losses. At the same time, this is a precaution in the event that one pole should go down.

A number of tests are scheduled for the coming months. Eight Siemens engineers, accommodated in an office above the valve hall, sit in the control room, gradually ramping up the voltage onscreen. This is designed to push the components to their very limits and reveal any weaknesses before the system enters service. A blackout in one of China’s large coastal cities would be a nightmare.

The left half of a large control screen displays the operating load of the transmission station in Lufeng as "0 MW." The right side of the screen shows the status of the receiving station in Guangzhou, where the direct current will be converted back into alternating current and fed into the public grid. Here a default reading of "9.999 MW" is displayed. Were the station in operation, the screen would show a power of 5,000 MW as well as a raft of other data from Guangzhou, all of which will be transferred in real time via a fiber optic cable that is laid along the HVDC transmission route.

Know-how from East and West. Whereas the AC part of the system was built entirely by Chinese firms, the DC part contains a lot of Siemens know-how. Yet that doesn’t mean that all the components were made in Germany. Half of the 48 transformers are of German production, while the others were manufactured in China under the supervision of Siemens.

Sawatzki has been in China for ten years now. The HVDCT system in Lufeng is his fourth for network operator China Southern Power Grid. All in all, the project will take three years, from the award of contract in June 2007 to full commissioning in June 2010.

In the first project with China Southern Power Grid, Siemens handled 80 % of the total contract volume, in the second 60 %, and in the third 40 %. In the fourth project this share has fallen a bit further, coming in at around €370 million out of the €1 billion that the system is costing. China Southern Power Grid has stipulated that most of the components to be supplied by Siemens must be manufactured in China by subcontractors. So whereas Siemens is still responsible for the engineering of the thyristors, for example, these components and all the ancillary equipment are being manufactured under Siemens supervision by two Chinese firms.

Profiting from Innovation. It will not be possible, however, to build future systems of this kind without Siemens’ know-how, since innovation is continuously advancing the state of the art in this field. "There’s a lot of new know-how in the 800 kV technology, which is being used here for the first time," explains Susanne Vowinkel, who works at Siemens’ Energy Sector as a commercial project manager in the field of contracts, issuing invitations to tender to suppliers, and customer relations.

Innovations from Siemens include silicone-covered insulators that repel water and provide better insulation when dirty. Meanwhile, engineers are already looking beyond the 800 kV mark, as higher transmission voltages promise even lower line losses. The move from 500 kV to 800 kV has already reduced costs over 30 years by around one quarter. The name of the game, as Vowinkel points out, is to stay one step ahead.

Siemens has just landed a major contract in India and tendered bids for further HVDCT projects in China, India, the U.S., and New Zealand. What’s more, HVDCT has already become the cornerstone of major projects for the future, such as Desertec, which will transmit power from North Africa and the Middle East to Europe (see article "Desert Power").

Bernd Müller